After sitting on an inherited record collection for far too long, I am about to start catag over 4,000 LPs. My question is this: for a factory sealed record, what is better for its value -- to leave it sealed or to open it to learn more about the pressing?
Example: John Coltrane's SD-1361 will reveal 172 variations... (I think I narrowed it down to a 1975 reissue based on the album cover). Open it to learn more to confirm pressing or leave it "as is"?
In general a sealed copy is worth more than a unsealed one. A exception would be if unsealed to confirm a ”first press” or a specially sought after pressing.
A problem with selling sealed copies on discogs is that here you have to list it under the correct version and sometimes that is hard/impossible with sealed records. Wich can lead to negative and possibly other things.
Thanks -- as I am just getting my toes wet (have only added 2 LPs to collection, out of 4500, so far), my feelings were in-line with what you have stated. I would never want to be inaccurate with the LP pressing or its condition (and hopefully won't make too many mistakes along the way). My instincts tell me to leave a "unimportant" pressing sealed (as I believe to be the case in my example) and, only unseal (as minimally as possible) something I need to confirm to be a more valuable pressing. For the time being, I am just in the catag stage... selling might not come for a while!